NXT Season 2 Rookies: Where Are They Now?

Ah, NXT Season 2! Guys, remember that rollercoaster? It feels like ages ago, doesn't it? We saw some real talent, some… well, let's just say not everyone becomes a main-eventer. But hey, that's the beauty of wrestling, right? Not everyone can be John Cena! Let's dive into what happened to the rookies from NXT Season 2. Where are they now? What did they do after their time on the show? Get ready for a trip down memory lane!

The Rookies and Their Mentors

Let's kick things off by remembering who was actually in NXT Season 2. We had eight hungry rookies all vying for that top spot, each paired with a WWE pro as their mentor. This mentor-rookie dynamic was a central part of the show's concept, intended to help guide and shape the newcomers. But, as wrestling fate would have it, things don't always go according to plan!

Here's a quick rundown:

• Alex Riley, mentored by The Miz.
• Eli Cottonwood, mentored by John Morrison.
• Husky Harris, mentored by Cody Rhodes.
• Kaval, mentored by Michelle McCool.
• Lucky Cannon, mentored by Mark Henry.
• Michael McGillicutty, mentored by Kofi Kingston.
• Percy Watson, mentored by MVP.
• Titus O'Neil, mentored by Zack Ryder.

It's actually quite a diverse group when you look back! You've got a mix of styles, sizes, and personalities, all thrown together in the WWE developmental system. Some of these names you'll recognize instantly; others might require a bit of jogging your memory. But each of them played a part in what made NXT Season 2… well, NXT Season 2.

The mentors themselves were a pretty interesting bunch too. Some were established main-event guys, while others were still finding their footing. The mentor role was a good way to get them involved in the developmental process and give them a chance to showcase their leadership skills, or lack thereof! Either way, the dynamic between the rookies and their mentors provided plenty of entertainment and drama.

Where Are They Now?

Alright, let's get to the good stuff! What happened to these NXT Season 2 rookies after their time on the show? Did they go on to WWE stardom, fade into obscurity, or find success elsewhere? The answers might surprise you.

Alex Riley

Oh, A-Ry! He was definitely one of the more memorable rookies from that season, largely thanks to his connection with The Miz. Alex Riley had the look, the athleticism, and the charisma to potentially make it big. After NXT, he aligned himself with The Miz on the main roster and even had a run with the United States Championship. His commentary career was also notable.

However, things eventually fizzled out. He faced injuries and never quite reached that top-tier level. Riley was released from WWE in 2016 and has since pursued other ventures, including acting and painting. While his WWE career might not have reached its full potential, he remains a memorable figure from that era.

Eli Cottonwood

Okay, let's be honest. Eli Cottonwood was a…project. He had the size that WWE loves, but he was still very green in the ring. His time on NXT didn't exactly set the world on fire, and he was eventually released. After WWE, Cottonwood seems to have stepped away from the wrestling world entirely. Details about his current endeavors are scarce, but it's safe to say he's moved on to other things. Some talents just don't quite click, and that's perfectly okay!

Husky Harris (Bray Wyatt)

Now this is a success story! Husky Harris might not have impressed everyone on NXT Season 2, but look at what he became! After a brief repackaging, he returned to WWE as Bray Wyatt, the leader of the Wyatt Family. With his dark charisma, his unsettling promos, and his unique in-ring style, Wyatt became one of the most captivating and innovative performers of his generation. He won multiple championships and delivered countless memorable moments. Sadly, Bray Wyatt, real name Windham Rotunda, passed away on August 24, 2023, at the age of 36.

Kaval (Low Ki)

Kaval was the winner of NXT Season 2, but his WWE career was surprisingly short-lived. Despite his talent and experience as Low Ki on the independent scene, he didn't quite click with the WWE audience. After a brief run, he requested his release and returned to the indies, where he continued to have a successful career. Low Ki has wrestled all over the world, known for his stiff strikes and intense style. He's a respected veteran in the wrestling world and a testament to the fact that success isn't always defined by WWE.

Lucky Cannon

Lucky Cannon's time in WWE was brief and largely unremarkable. He didn't make a huge impression on NXT, and he was released shortly after the season ended. Like Eli Cottonwood, he seems to have disappeared from the wrestling scene. Sometimes, things just don't work out, and that's perfectly fine. Not everyone is destined for wrestling glory.

Michael McGillicutty (Curtis Axel)

Michael McGillicutty, the son of Mr. Perfect Curt Hennig, had a decent WWE career after his time on NXT. He was repackaged as Curtis Axel and even became an Intercontinental Champion. While he never reached the same heights as his legendary father, he carved out a solid career for himself as a reliable mid-card performer. After his WWE run, he worked as a coach at the Performance Center. Axel was released from WWE in 2020.

Percy Watson

Percy Watson was known for his charismatic personality and his high-energy style. After NXT, he had a decent run on the main roster before transitioning to a role as a commentator. He's become a familiar voice on NXT and other WWE programming, showcasing his knowledge and enthusiasm for the sport. Percy found his niche in the commentary booth, demonstrating that there are many paths to success in the wrestling world.

Titus O'Neil

Titus O'Neil is perhaps one of the biggest success stories from NXT Season 2, not just in terms of in-ring accomplishments, but also in terms of his contributions to the community. While he may not have been a world champion, Titus became a beloved figure in WWE for his philanthropy and his positive attitude. He's involved in numerous charitable endeavors and is known for his work with underprivileged youth. Titus is a true inspiration and a shining example of how wrestlers can use their platform to make a positive impact on the world. He continues to be a valuable member of the WWE roster and a role model for many.

Final Thoughts

So, there you have it! A look back at the rookies of NXT Season 2 and what they've been up to since then. Some went on to WWE stardom, some found success elsewhere, and some faded into obscurity. But each of them played a part in the history of NXT and the evolution of WWE. It's a reminder that the wrestling world is full of surprises, and you never know where someone's journey might take them. It's fascinating to see how these careers have unfolded and how each of these guys has made their mark in their own way. Guys, isn't wrestling history awesome?